Most people who hire a tax preparer do so in good faith. They hand over their W-2s, answer a few questions, sign where they’re told to sign, and trust that a professional is handling everything correctly. For the vast majority of taxpayers, that trust is well-placed.
But not always.
Tax preparer fraud is a genuine and growing problem — one that leaves victims not just financially damaged, but legally exposed. Because here’s the part that shocks most people: when a dishonest tax preparer files a fraudulent return in your name, the IRS holds you responsible for it. Not the preparer. You.
Understanding what tax preparer fraud looks like, how to spot warning signs before you become a victim, and what to do if it’s already happened to you is essential knowledge for anyone who doesn’t prepare their own taxes.
What Is Tax Preparer Fraud?
Tax preparer fraud occurs when a paid tax preparer deliberately falsifies information on a client’s return — or files returns without the client’s knowledge — in order to generate inflated refunds, steal those refunds, or collect fees based on a percentage of the refund.
It takes many forms. Some preparers fabricate deductions — charitable contributions, business expenses, medical costs — that the taxpayer never actually incurred. Others claim credits the taxpayer doesn’t qualify for, such as the Earned Income Tax Credit, by misrepresenting income levels or the number of dependents. Some preparers alter direct deposit information so the refund goes to their own account instead of the client’s. In particularly brazen cases, preparers file returns for clients without their knowledge at all, pocket the refund, and the taxpayer only finds out when the IRS contacts them about a return they never authorized.
What all of these schemes have in common is that the preparer benefits — through fees, stolen refunds, or repeat business from clients who believe they’re getting unusually large refunds — while the taxpayer is left holding the bag when the IRS catches up.
How Does the IRS Catch Tax Preparer Fraud?
The IRS has sophisticated systems for identifying returns that look unusual — refund amounts that are disproportionately large relative to income, deductions that exceed what is typical for a given income level, patterns of identical or near-identical returns filed by the same preparer, or credits claimed at unusually high rates. The IRS also tracks preparers who consistently produce returns with errors or inflated refunds.
When the IRS flags a return, they investigate. And when that investigation reveals fraud, they go after the preparer — but they also contact the taxpayer, because the liability for the understated tax, interest, and penalties attaches to the return itself, not just to the person who prepared it.
This is the part that feels profoundly unfair, and in many ways it is. But it’s the law. Signing a tax return means you’re attesting that the information is accurate to the best of your knowledge. Even if you had no idea your preparer was fabricating deductions, the IRS can hold you responsible for the resulting tax deficiency.
Warning Signs of a Fraudulent Tax Preparer
Prevention is far easier than recovery. Here are the red flags that should make you think twice before signing anything:
They promise a large refund before seeing your documents. Legitimate tax preparers don’t know what your refund will be until they’ve reviewed your actual financial information. A preparer who guarantees a large refund upfront is almost certainly planning to manipulate your return to produce it.
They charge fees based on a percentage of your refund. This fee structure creates a direct financial incentive to inflate your refund — the bigger the refund, the bigger their fee. Reputable preparers charge flat fees or hourly rates.
They ask you to sign a blank return. Never sign a blank or incomplete tax return under any circumstances. This gives the preparer carte blanche to put whatever they want on your return after you’ve signed it.
They don’t have a Preparer Tax Identification Number (PTIN). Anyone who is paid to prepare federal tax returns is legally required to have a PTIN issued by the IRS. Ask for it. You can verify it through the IRS’s online preparer directory at irs.gov.
They suggest directing your refund to their account. Your refund should always go directly to your personal bank account or be issued as a check in your name. No legitimate preparer should ever ask you to route your refund through them.
They don’t sign the return themselves. Paid preparers are required to sign the returns they prepare and include their PTIN. A preparer who leaves this blank is either operating illegally or trying to avoid accountability.
The return doesn’t match what you provided. Before you sign, review the entire return. Check that your income is accurately reported, that the deductions reflect things you actually spent money on, and that the refund amount seems reasonable given your financial situation. If something doesn’t look right, ask questions — or walk away.
What to Do If You’ve Already Been a Victim
If you discover that your tax preparer filed a fraudulent return in your name — whether you’ve received an IRS notice, noticed a missing refund, or found out some other way — here’s what to do:
Stop using that preparer immediately. This sounds obvious, but some victims continue working with a fraudulent preparer out of loyalty, fear, or confusion about what happened. Cut ties immediately.
Contact the IRS. Report the fraudulent preparer to the IRS using Form 14157, Complaint: Tax Return Preparer, and if you believe the preparer filed a return without your authorization or altered your return after you signed it, also file Form 14157-A, Tax Return Preparer Fraud or Misconduct Affidavit. These forms initiate an IRS investigation into the preparer.
Request an audit reconsideration. If the IRS has assessed additional tax based on the fraudulent return, you may be able to request an audit reconsideration — a process where the IRS reviews the assessment again in light of new information. Documenting what you actually reported and what the preparer changed is central to this process.
Consider reasonable cause penalty relief. Depending on the circumstances, there may be arguments available under the reasonable cause standard that can reduce or eliminate penalties — particularly if you can demonstrate that you relied in good faith on a professional and had no reason to know the return was fraudulent.
Get professional representation. Dealing with the aftermath of tax preparer fraud is complicated. You’re potentially dealing with an IRS examination, a fraud investigation, a civil or criminal case against the preparer, and your own tax liability — all at the same time. Having an experienced tax resolution professional in your corner is not optional in this situation.
Reporting a Fraudulent Preparer
Beyond filing Forms 14157 and 14157-A with the IRS, you can also report fraudulent preparers to the IRS Office of Professional Responsibility, which has authority to discipline or bar preparers from federal tax practice. If the preparer is a CPA, attorney, or enrolled agent, you can also report them to the relevant state licensing board.
The FTC’s consumer complaint database and your state attorney general’s office are additional reporting avenues, particularly if the fraud involved theft of your refund or identity.
Reporting matters — not just for your own case, but because it helps protect other taxpayers who might otherwise become the next victim of the same preparer.
How to Choose a Trustworthy Tax Preparer Going Forward
For the future, here are the basics of choosing someone you can trust. Verify their PTIN through the IRS preparer directory. If they’re a CPA, attorney, or enrolled agent, verify their credentials and standing with the relevant licensing body. Ask how they charge — flat fee or hourly is a better sign than a percentage of your refund. Ask to review the completed return before signing and don’t be rushed. Make sure they sign the return and include their PTIN. And trust your instincts — if something feels off, it probably is.
The Bottom Line
Tax preparer fraud is a problem that can follow you for years — in the form of IRS notices, audits, assessments, penalties, and the stress of untangling someone else’s dishonesty from your financial life. The best protection is knowing the warning signs before you sign anything. The second-best protection is knowing what to do immediately if it’s already happened.
At Brightside Tax Relief, we help clients navigate the aftermath of tax preparer fraud — from responding to IRS notices and requesting audit reconsideration to building the strongest possible case for penalty relief. If you’ve been victimized by a dishonest preparer, you don’t have to face the IRS alone.
Call us today at 914-214-9127 or visit brightsidetaxrelief.com. Let’s start untangling this together.
The information in this article is for general educational purposes only and does not constitute legal or tax advice. Every tax situation is unique. Contact a qualified tax professional for guidance specific to your circumstances.
Need Tax Help?
Our licensed attorneys are ready to help you resolve your IRS tax issues — free consultation, no obligation.